volume: issue, issue:
The accurate estimation of earthwork volume, which constitutes the primary cost driver in road planning and construction, is crucial for project budget management and environmental sustainability. This study conducts a comparative analysis of traditional versus modern estimation techniques along an existing road alignment in the Istanbul University-Cerrahpaşa Research Forest. High-resolution terrain data, acquired via Real-Time Kinematic Global Navigation Satellite System (RTK-GNSS) and Total Station integrated surveys, were used to test the Average End Area, Prismoidal, Simplified Applicable Lengths, and Pappus-based methods utilizing both field-measured and standard template cross-sections. In the context of computer-aided design (CAD) analyses, models incorporating varying cross-section intervals and sampling strategies were generated using AutoCAD Civil 3D, and the resulting volume estimates were subjected to statistical evaluation. Results indicated that calculations based on field-measured cross-sections resulted in a significant »fill deficit«, whereas the use of standard template cross-sections consistently led to a distinct »cut surplus«. Among traditional methods, the Prismoidal and Pappus-based methods produced the most precise results, whereas the widely used Average End Area Method overestimated earthwork volumes. In computer-aided approaches, automatic cross-section sampling based on road geometry and 5-meter fixed interval modeling yielded no statistically significant difference from the reference method – defined as the arithmetic mean of the Average End Area and Prismoidal results at 1 m cross-section intervals in Civil 3D – confirming their reliability. These findings highlight the importance of employing 5-meter interval modeling in CAD environments for optimal alignment selection. Furthermore, the study advocates for the use of the Pappus-based method in traditional calculations due to its consideration of the horizontal curvature effect.
volume: 48, issue: 1
The accurate estimation of earthwork volume, which constitutes the primary cost driver in road planning and construction, is crucial for project budget management and environmental sustainability. This study conducts a comparative analysis of traditional versus modern estimation techniques along an existing road alignment in the Istanbul University-Cerrahpaşa Research Forest. High-resolution terrain data, acquired via Real-Time Kinematic Global Navigation Satellite System (RTK-GNSS) and Total Station integrated surveys, were used to test the Average End Area, Prismoidal, Simplified Applicable Lengths, and Pappus-based methods utilizing both field-measured and standard template cross-sections. In the context of computer-aided design (CAD) analyses, models incorporating varying cross-section intervals and sampling strategies were generated using AutoCAD Civil 3D, and the resulting volume estimates were subjected to statistical evaluation. Results indicated that calculations based on field-measured cross-sections resulted in a significant »fill deficit«, whereas the use of standard template cross-sections consistently led to a distinct »cut surplus«. Among traditional methods, the Prismoidal and Pappus-based methods produced the most precise results, whereas the widely used Average End Area Method overestimated earthwork volumes. In computer-aided approaches, automatic cross-section sampling based on road geometry and 5-meter fixed interval modeling yielded no statistically significant difference from the reference method – defined as the arithmetic mean of the Average End Area and Prismoidal results at 1 m cross-section intervals in Civil 3D – confirming their reliability. These findings highlight the importance of employing 5-meter interval modeling in CAD environments for optimal alignment selection. Furthermore, the study advocates for the use of the Pappus-based method in traditional calculations due to its consideration of the horizontal curvature effect.